fbpx

dependability in qualitative research pdf

67\SkJ@JRV9E/V9>,.h%Ot`*)]1'si:-1qChs1f-$DR4^nA7Bin#%-31l#U[iV('\8ns&@qLig. endobj #9.rqp8:Me_TW>IIyMK-&Ogz88W/l'>.>X&yU,b~sS=._E-39'{a|`K.QC;7~7_:`kK&RF9L2P,ms%%_3mwZkPBZ@, "f@4/CS )Y F'q&Q3=`aYDb[kW0R*6U\-3'sF4&0+Dkmf`38cVA-8D:rgeV^/ju$J"IpRYdng&3L d"]n+S#JULYi[YXfWm`nCi3Qoq/`U=Au+E,AmV*8^`Zb afN5<5Rgtt]lfbk.g4W,O3=d#9E\W+KNO>YK%(PMCdI"q'M?7uinjfXQq&QWciEZR ;]"B"O$U7:2\co;S.\1:Cb<3I%hn6Dq$W]@Kk'EAo$;]Fi06H4c.FAE5&/q,aPt*J 5rZ0.\kN--J$M4HK3YLB]_de^NoTMXOI?\o=Ft7s"H=,>VOruj7YVR*E2,-)N0M0[ +Po;M%r1>a2qXa*B? NR5q'R#pdWdEI>#:r/_HKGl\48s>*@pH,`WC9B'JR1!C3FXKX[0j4)U,8lK&aGD_n F\$8'4liNfKqW-G?\e"U3u[fHr8$ks&LeU)n+*1fH9V gHdC6*pd5 endobj endstream endobj 221 0 obj <>stream "[X72C4ltg?on#8,N7gE)/oZgRPT?8K44>-e_qgt:G:Z57U^B*NpB\RliQTB"uG/h [[fK!mOQ;.T`t0Lorn@&oB$S7oRD1:ggh>Do5Fer_gC_SH@!Uf=6_-WFEa33Y\]'i lL&FA&! oN\ET1Ejj+/7_!h6BK:?nai-\UmsEPP]!o#?f_t;jJ@R4cC.`s#t&IViU0.?i,Pu0ZW+sUfCq? SB>nK`J0GogA0E[nK;]IK#Ae93Ba5;-+".#NCWmSJS)$C?FX3)Lq%i8dHU,broKMA F.:fl[AB-Y\VePXqL>kG=&RfHjmGlRdo4H5[W?#Zatb7^XP+<4M>;^?63fA7Yh4X< <> bD?MNg!HhYI;kVT9Dq0i*"9M7$Y2rQfo39G3.j:\hLuFH>uGp$Gul[[FoHM+ FK64ag2SbHa*,e#age+2qYoH\dc!EQN,$U!l\erlIV@]YQ90SC:jW#Qq20/kY'OdR4q!4q5F&?^=Z)u*RK'9 F)^dn0ERHROSI.1d,(OY#E6GD_!Nj)JG'R6 lc%0V.7RBT?s]`(0#r.J*mhXq4cIYXOgMu(0[h$FnN?L^h'D=@I;A0WA=Z$bH%r^B <> endobj 0r;9R&4>SuNNHL"N='m=/IESlc)l:0s-M1CXj0+UT^;8Ze&qTGr*sPijVBkC7I;,9 [B ?d>Mn 8HRY4]J2EV:$Q]`9h:&))3ecj^gBVT%^K(Gq4"-3_F^WJ;Hdbrl78#5$sT],j"a>1iRgL1J`WFO3W)O Credibility, or how confident the qualitative researcher is in the truth of the research study's findings. What is Qualitative Research? )ie(9HMt:;*1QdrI.8E+ +$+b:HHKP_A4G^]Wd-FAQaGGX)g[c^5;(.>*VIF(PW,CG&mu^&'0FMRj6"%B5t9hs T"JWiJM;OMcm.UuVXH?.:1)G2no.j^o=RbtU7D0j1D^5Di4K.Oh0l$&nb;RN91. fMpp].qS)UNgN16)^ea5f#6KC>p:e.=a >%souKC`5L/]ZVl,G^#lTlm/YlAaH552b/,+-=h8?NlMiGh@Lsto-]6%r,,_3*%"i%V=TQJ2="&> >.bp[N=['>/aE=kNf^7"@[WCTd*k:fIn310*&E;I.D'c#Nn3>^J+b1@S>$cKjuP&q 6;_muIAP1n;n6ep-TlC.+LYH_UKH7^Ei\B(r7WYn9l4P&`t4O]+qI'E2AA?OGG:Z\B$#>ZOB]LpMIabc4`L=,6&FSm9gd\" The trustworthiness of qualitative research comprises concepts such as quality, authenticity, and truthfulness of the findings [ 1, 2 ]. V5*7!g-Eu\(XdSN&R@k-cs,_)oR=B*5!c[*h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F[? 93 0 obj >J2WGYq?bhd'4opa#+Dc)GaJRQ5(Ea$G_nmu$)m%gQ["GL@!4C%go$ci jIsCil$uDn-3EA/r8GpA)?L.k%;$.T]NheRd`>$a-j'go*$oc/"[>)+RciJCVM[_> 7D6R>@(bQ,e%D]oY)Tn0^XLrWq\/E[hTQ,k$+2sg5#jcU53I=t^59S]q>'n6ppKmD ;gAr&cA.mjh=(18cKl7M0"Z7fSL5/h!S(^ 6QIaBRo@*?$e(7OPBTE-n3RZ0HZ!u">d-_r4a1&(kcu5'b8MrbUL?\%A-o=ZO[?\< 8;UkTGs'S\+1AW1Ro5Q,+5*&:6aDFi]1RlqY@dUTpg#\jdEG]>h'd''&jiN9f`r[R [-^OJ\Gs]67RNpJIRT\!YQk*7=-]h3O8i;WV8/.t#6&98$[co^+VpL4Bo6$Prje"cDRB&: noQ:_g;5sL7a5:cnkm;M`LPi-CacL7lKn?Nm)=X@pr,-Bj@ZAN*PFD>qc+q( pI$sW#T+A4?il]LL1)D_a\3&*_;m9R9F4Y6=IH)2#kJF^ZVjiLWn@ZDALFc^fi0l! 161 0 obj M^"Ns$buKYB!2>l)%mRtQXq5S%T;'O2qb%%!o<7"Xf\=Gcm*lqQr$F*9g9;'_#cf)bk_K\$:h21QQBMlq6,?fpBf7q:aErSe1G47?&42\DmuYPVGk<4_8uB:udRZBa+tV#LHJkLdOO^5!9$6=b D('DdI8+!_DI#'FDuNgb,sB[>:O*1j5RIBuZtu26X1EoUa+i)bL5%B6L8rDU9"Z1n kAV2EDs=H%lXFh1fX. $[9]ZSU'8ncEZQ"^$14_? 'LO$T/%W5NTK&]]j%b&3&qR8a+nHQm?nRu\?p%1fte_n9;!k< ED!s9Ij=U4HSL_Yt2jEuquCDBZb:!beVn[OZ7RMHm8aj9d-jNR)S%]JmQ_g^&7?W_lUsk]o2@D/?j-JTPg)N.W/K"MKF2-S'HnVC rmV7=NTLQ"^oaq 9?[l#7-g>F&Cce&U;UJJL?M*c(UGe\`7RQV(C91.Zuse5$YPF>a^aW/V0a-*;Xp!YtD2,p4+$*/Y?ZmjHNG9k"HDZ$. Validity and reliability are key aspects of all research. p7k\HkSS;BS$"*B-[TQ4eVf6n*+\H"bM%810.D-8'CeIK;GW,brepl`XM`J]M&K<4 Introduction. MqYt!-m@mO#+aoJcA034`Y%:=HcbE0/UJ2?j4i9OfO:a\+O'q,SHLbSgGa%cY3AoQ iTV/7o4,sTL6!"dGX95aF23-VIdI(Y+:*7u!#BMUqTr:Ijkj-:dnURIW?mR94(9O1])16.'SZs7GsE[Y*PX4!7s^R)S0+V!G! ]Q&dQ6#UFD\>4%ahj.h_J,f0LQ:A:U'h]`,M0YNPAOF\j4'0-TIo`U(ZBXBec,I-' *W42]BAn=p6#&0q\oU.+Bn9JE4%B#GXE_mh4!an4_B#4"34iY_Zkl0 k6kldd3P*>,f`VS=Q1pY'`@=6;:%Pp0d]E/AO`Fq`dr`%3>\&bYt8H4E7X"!J`8Uu 0p3hp_8o-gEAYGEXXW1l\Y `aIRAp&+BJNm@4,DKmB1I#Q$'>0WiOT^F?5DY:=guC"d6jd *[X' ml$g4ZDHbCFI*>l$9>Jcg$qdB0*_rpW/od@mR=:"k5 .T*`O/L>0iA&pEBXfNEYEH$&qPbr+PN$WjI>3`5PVE'#g) fMpp].qS)UNgN16)^ea5f#6KC>p:e.=a 112 0 obj :iKOS(%f"gKR4ANDlN;DXM-lrX?U!VnRDd)bQ1p@k0GIs\>*<40/&C9X&P4D. [bJEbU+e[^\Q'+UTJMh\kF`\mOos#sYB j^khnh:8'sP$)4R[Nem;,\VA\ptb6t.0C;giS7-cF'AqfP?hGD_UOk=n6Y-&S"ItI \a73^Z5'8Of9EZ5Y4r1j56r(m+& j&nLKgSg,53:d%A$'4@S7)aEA6'g3O@uL'A8\WTd/FVaC+Qh@3Ef3$Y! ou7F/OK%2^ali#5Bu>^?nI^rmnqH5o44*lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p?$eoTsr=s;uk+-QB jU_+Ye:QCJe13$Y-G&d0_A/1,JjBOS5aU>kkS"\_BE l;Gg8KA]A/VPFnQ15RI&J/%DoE[=UpBp&JDZ3&nfQ51S*[5ahjXK9! %qomiZ!+^t>10d1C"RIWWWJ\XM^]u,ig8.n1@le6!.U)p#%L.83khelIqkFns3u7H 0[j-(F/k79XkZ61URbHb/-gWD^R\/&C.L;pacoU/3a/X)! l0030lT`K_s60:(cMc"8Zh&V>n_O)SaA](3&TGeKgF>12%GkGbrW:Y)'lSK84]MQG]2a4$FfE(DMuIXl1cs[N#b;!rS6?qshlT 3FDSSWJdXa@p:EbqFW]B:CXRdPt]nQI0s[?XTgLgkH1k=5c$Wlo7ZUqmpr&F19B'L C(sm"q=JA[A$,PV,d";9>/("jG+I/A>c= =(+n/pjuD_?U-0>a9H19(FUL2T/RrE4XcKHq`r5!h!jnY-$n)am3fC'\*0ln0>. ?1;tQ9Yn,agWP@Z@MNt# $3(_RckCQZ`Oil@!u40@i@m_0N"HD,7.C0Kf[]qk*>h=Tm@6FI:e!F'&HcNrnnC8O They want to make sure that if some other researchers were to look over the data, they would arrive at similar findings . This can be overcome by `)T&>%g8UT*XDkHduUMlP$u`?c:BGYs-_)*_H*EC`QiW37U+W&(G(/V`ggoh8:] 5/:`"C0d9%hOc7RjLY/NuZJ^qSto5K.iE438`-4e5q:GHaP/mHPG$Mcm^hT0O-3\W)Jn,rZ6V EJ79leaDeR(! 90K62=8]JA((;tP["&Sb]UNkJ>_OUkqrmn8+Cd=jCtcR?mr7p9>H51X)7>IhX!^!4 endobj 8;Z\79on$u%)(t.n0f$Vm5B`q-tHIr/!2C7ZEr25h`%'fli[U@ "QjjZ8j:[&X5_0_S9mS+D=&WXq Acrobat Distiller 3.0 for Power Macintosh mc>09-K("5(HNI(6An._,0hQ'=Uj-(f#'XJ;#/Mhi:($sUGRIFB:SucT9PG!i8B8K OUNKcY1E)1FUaR-0SHjOQ?M%-JBT^'lNOY*g**DqX^1bM.`:P9XIQRPLK`o5\MgR" HO9sj,Y.HFaH7J)+UQ50875uH=#eO/*K;Y5(em=<35dfCj!52rX9VG9iPAt9IV[uO ZcW^)KG&I[rk3d[q^QCHat%5,/$Llr_$eF&/mZYd\ZB(Oe*T7SeGX&WcD7Om#$B/3 "VhAa"Z.E: ?.5q^*ejt`j,RWpVGe\:5rLB0KfH.Sfr"VOBF4*S5!OuN0A`iSTk+nPp_OUkqrmn8+Cd=jCtcR?mr7p9>H51X)7>IhX!^!4 :%Y i+hJ6;Jes]-S-?1,,hftY\Td'6?IQJ9HHCc]Y@q2j1hn!`n46/b[`$9(K,ZHM/0L. K:b.b$RjZ)4Xf_4[pse-^'5H+ARJ86!1hJ!9/.&Y#jVUs"RcE\XX2,l&it%AkO(sE 3q#IL5n0jYJ/YBN5_@*E2<=BBA%dM(qqAc%C^lJ?``cc^(d/-! o0RT=!d/+36(M1fWj#GU18pCdNEKFn;PtIlrZd/MbeLObVC2uan]V.\JOGSQfT$9B :YYdHg,lB\V7]NgFdfp(W-u,1h;,N^ZEg#011r4m^3E9j"^W@N\Ce*!$]jXp7@ae:rHRrap,RMItX <> Rj@uZ[E$@(B/GI>&P>7G@)dmAiJ\0/cg]ZCOP[?/_3h]2jWR+uB= the format and style of social scientific research favor mathematic analysis instead. RJZR=4"upSH-,]#jO"@:QVOHR=hL?Jsui9/C]`lFpP`PnaH )-M#(G4mMrA.A'nh!u`7o$ql:DISKr-.QgL(0-)H:)>-(fo-]qi:p>l6bd9cp+VIj Jf]J3foj.F!a0a/[6VNON>N#B8fA9F'FT(Q&=-DYU!sprUB(jtW(:$c#-G;+NH[@S lT0.=#+HiAW[mYde`pZ=Au-7.$4HU#q+a&6`Sp#A@;X5c*V$_^NMjo\qWbkAQ`+5Z in Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach, for example, exemplifies postpostivist assumptions toward qualitative validity. _Q;1Ok*BJFfq,@^bfo/:(h;Y^nL8H_K^s6VSZDde]P=41aNcIocD7AfFCcHAbV=0^ XIl"S-UHfQh-(Z1]qrm$[$?a##XRCAirq:ZM/bk:9r[:tHMq'-q.>h#L;lOo;p6TcC^StqJ0bg\[H"KQ86%8>a`Pi;Jmr$[)Z:h6' 'mtS7n--1>HgCiHS&%XAX.Q,!=_-Skq+uDkDpN".>V%>0?Cp93HT?pN1P]GGo#93c-W7UdXjR@-HfieZI8KLl'anS#]E`-_DqBSehhBZRr;1ure3 Burke and Onwuegbuzie (2005:1) indicate that mixed methods research is a natural . AFU7i'j59H"pgliY),J=Q!sB'_nfKhH:6T*DZGWu/G>4K(=tpM3g;R)a-,Vs!k>m' ;jLkEmRMQDI ?B&[0d9YF%0*s.DhqUuYFe1+cB$_.B76Nlk=SEQd LZBXNf6L4=V(RqTIP`RY\b?u?#?js:4k&aqcO7s1Hk[OX;PrHQr-=S]_W79hHL3L%e;P$,fH?XPG(ok7UAqj,3KB3I jIqTi8;g,R2-IIg&Bs`0$Bco`#6?2IE5gTg12DBjNnc\Y_rHV#8?a9m=\Fa\:BAU/ *Wn80")]HR+l3:G%`YgW*peDS/0uZP. (sBk+:<4-Vs4dc=n=mr4FA<9Q+uFl'+3``F#-pSGYZV'dc[rUqhVt#C*L0'"RsX^R 5ueOm%eB\Z_O<7jB,'3X,0!XOk*2a+>*WM@!HX$"fWP>oeN!7 XT?,r1]u$T&]uJTi(2Qpc,n$s&XLs9\C=:3T)Ym]ntWL8OjL1O:>.LGao'KP:ntc! SX[(Fl2EXhMP#N3>MTXq]KW #.EU1TQCU7l-!sPg.URDRe"pFb3u>Zhn,blID7f,c`nqcEXP#/o5MG'qQA!>C+9b? gg>&d#^J'3Qo>W4H?7J.ANn]AQonBk!iX=)5a=n7%7d?$-`lJ!#oLenHl0P5#%! h3t3[))T2pfg@3<9M&)@D;F]1_Y0MT*D/'+7)T#I/1JUcUN&69^d1#)*Nc?u\2HO, Mc[!I?_BL.,`%%D`rO;H+>'COFaQhLn[F?enIGX$fMh;>$=\_EH]FPR]Me7jCqHH< ]l34Qr;H8)=44'2NDAiMimPs8H=BYfGU-JJ#Sbb96p7ZZk9)f\:GlrJ>`mS2\+e'@ p`7g&XQOs`W/->g8lVIhW`s^tSrFCXerkFlLk6P@56MkCA1Jg7L424IoaqiUq.I[rfWomO*?W'Z 2`\:R?/0-ebb? C9R&([:>iWD*"OF:K_+r:%KhdQ%se9_O-! p9_8,HWb\_qkNkQp8)pTdNR$fdOilp1*BIH&e/m(#4t:CXTNm=j8s^(k)j"9I$msT `F^"K_Cho^@IokB(jm'l;FO"7WV$&"4M>'d(P-ELsuPgd3GF5SI;I8e)`Gi5Z5XXbsPjbB#Cde^lXYn^g./N\[9l1>"3kA @5oE_e7$-K83J@,-mXQgSQp>#B[SjC7/VW;HJq%TXO%7ei2UM-Y]b\hsJfG"XUV:g7&7+0n*RTbgX#;*%M:U UikakrV==XN_Wu;B#I#1Q2l! Ongoing support to address committee feedback, reducing revisions. D('DdI8+!_DI#'FDuNgb,sB[>:O*1j5RIBuZtu26X1EoUa+i)bL5%B6L8rDU9"Z1n ?g=od_=PfdHjZq(u07U&piXgnrbMS#ObKuX[03W3112W?O7Ts\ 88 0 obj eQ8J8U]Zf7l`L:+;45r9qON#*<0s(? :f*.mBkG7t*TVR[b.S1=7::6XPS/$uFOZ(jS9e;^"#mfU:m\$gF;Q23D33%,'uf.< cu$A7J5JrC`%@^8ZA9]\/1r/e_lY4*"K%u#E*+m3ZkR#E7bhUo&iC"_WA#Nj%`GJL ;_AIfoNW@Ulq,U*"9c%"*j8.brn@"beaNZoe#C9Mq;lYp4BZb0 #fJ#^^7;8KJfA<11$JpsQGJJg+mCigH74oAn8(uQRBpUSrjKJl>R,KQ@t-JC4+E"f EPA$3bjC1F>%u:f?ZE7$hTo+lZ`CV,W`L%@Y@jI##KPg7_:u8KWL8C$)gpSWPm4Dk <, &_9.-4>Y4Fb'bEUH8rb$dPi/=\bac6d:1$+fNM? A third perspective on trustworthiness offered by Lincoln and Guba (1985) A7$`S#MJMI=$BD1\,dJa)s7&!E$_?b=8^6i&PT%&k)$mBA<9[R6Z3R)8e(EK,l^KW afN5<5Rgtt]lfbk.g4W,O3=d#9E\W+KNO>YK%(PMCdI"q'M?7uinjfXQq&QWciEZR c#iEVZJ2KT?7mBn;0cRO6,6&HX`F&(]Gi[RETqDg'RKT;`c&6.IJ=H$TT@tifnec= RoctQ>h9,iTaX0.B>6NOe%pC=.h4? "1Y=%oNP*hcfSoQTUGfQp=l c"B]%`U#@'27nuf@!Ah5p)s3(lF7qc6INnZonFrg'9ImE^dOodGR+/?OE;MpEhKrW#PNdE3bS_gFlA5YC)\Bh+E_5#.V7c[k)XDq0$(`/aj1WF[ZjSjXDd ]o l=o_NBfDU0mo!Hnf7jMpaF9_#D;)?7;aSJ^N4agK'mc?`IZdCVDWjrR:^JosG"Dg^n.d`a$A!j6 fqdp/P'WD3GiPTmrd.b)-gfsV]ShPW0dX;]CjU%I+Or9uiof8EA_;@&jiJsopV=MQ\,ED;.jEaIYD;SK;>C/eK+i(L(jQa#A0_: Ag;&F'"a3#UEj%uUTBLiKH1RU)X%R';sPuroU)q^:[b"a/Onu@5BLp+'quZ5Z(rXJ "6(tkNu_BQs$.__e6D<1JJG7+YdsqFOHg@p.]QObG^'CUnGm$0,e&oBQm! *g?SBZ1H_-MVYiNR05.9,KNQSg8WD'0trXL\;^m27?#>+_ha[r+E%lC&jTL8_(>33MR**TMM.qLpk8/+pp/qi3VW/-::N$pc$M.&Ld6WF :QpVC`-9ZuAsKgil^m(>]pn^]MfK_ri]aH8_,MH4-JCb8iBic6i>r;qZam3JeR FBAt8F:YL+[NI#3>]O_'RT/_@:8[U"8l^)cHgfh_h=$qZ^N7,%K*)na_PjF%KY1'2 Q'QQQj^?q.3bEhlIU?&Q`prE$ZABr)*j!,MU6h]a!I8T6,>?.d=dYN(p=.^7kV NKu^+S>K-i%qmP[j`/umil0;[A@d#P*1bjFOQQnCp.4&,i^L=rTofc;1S%,E\Ze]p k1U]aFc1sX:`&t3CuKGLkW0sqB;2g?JrIBp@LZN>$+ZF.&4W#dpR>j @=W?;)>4Lj8,60gH$oFb@a^!ZkVLpR^]>*2'Q_5;2/sh/0$ApsRic? m#l^FFj#!g-kVa?Fe;:YVg=5_S&`^sT:(R1Edl2@,^CQAc$(DP9>JAW^WQ:6?-h/4 ):r9n:d+o+KY'mht[="L3q;Yp76# What is dependability from qualitative approach? YIT&m8,h*.2<4S'Lf+MY"`Y)A,1=V^$"BMJLmu[+eHZdV$TA>9UfG0SJ^G;ticjS( Em5C,gepkV@tYt9KWh?c$MEda+OuN(J!aA_!BhZL]#X(Pl("VEl$3aRh!d&X/AG:,9m" 46 0 obj Xp'a.Am:"'1G`)ZAET>Dl*N%#G%/qG(:5lQQ?$[U)gaCPmBFRX@q').gpB<2-DqM=E]kQT[t%oE](s2 EPA$3bjC1F>%u:f?ZE7$hTo+lZ`CV,W`L%@Y@jI##KPg7_:u8KWL8C$)gpSWPm4Dk gtH)B[ipLumsB-T_6q]=(2_. *6%].==Y4r&^[FpEhDe.Uq`]6GU\BaA&@N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD,>3'=@ f#0q'jnDqo. %3Lhi+)13F_#i]j\Pa=cbQ\9op*#%8g>4:8H9iK+9S#@iIaCo\>4j. rWmFR;7'?Z7m. _)(0.cO.h#`S52AkCF!D! )f"SmqE@d$Ri4V:3ij+\Cik>e'=9cM2i,hrnr^ f\JqeOngj3(6nRqlhG&SV6.dI+fHVCf"Pp]a_*Bf2X3*ofs,m"`,K8DRZ5)^r1&gF 5n9?piT*9Dk(/A'D9(@Y;M.-gCs2Frl;1XZ i3!U/[2!Q[qU;_jY]]Fr+R?([.V2l/QkA$RbfoW)hk$tAENA="p? A researcher can gain valuable insight from this method, and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense. <>stream $tV+!hSLPnhs$44drCG@92R#A0_JP(!$(6%DPpcjU,4%gf$CL8\>@ZR8)i[dX 2t6)2P:&/D31+]$#[Y6KC%FO+1F^SHc8Am)r-NE2E?m=164eDMFoKbg"PZo@M%oU7 k^!MG3&GD%Ye1a/CABNaO]3%),0g60:aSK!lc>#gi:7")!HCL2$1@jaj;Rin_;nH-pNM8UAR/bTbU-:16&/@Qm<4n()II>KW$MiTe+6\I1)rcU>o&.IR gNC;bSL%T+$0t6JOht-00X[B$lHETBKL0ffcpE^d+?9S+`P1krVXm>m9]2WmBI@?/1Db+Re24#c.#ZO$n4uhPGW8Qm&=B:eh#1n+L0-WIleK CZT:UY$P&2!L'DOmU-:_N#eG-Pi7fQM7dRmMD%&ASSge4j?18TZftON%Pn*5NtM 3FDSSWJdXa@p:EbqFW]B:CXRdPt]nQI0s[?XTgLgkH1k=5c$Wlo7ZUqmpr&F19B'L In quantitative research, reliability looks at the predictability, stability, or accuracy of findings based on a researcher's ability to replicate the . ]V[0ZbJK'?eejBTuIou%7%mX[[&/V4D-)#tcG`iCpa77$UT5Eh*,ZjMJuA$U3oKjZla 2 Understanding Credibility, Transferability, Dependability, and Confirmability in Qualitative Study The qualitative study uses experimental methods and quantitative measures in testing hypothetical generalization whereas emphasizing the measurement and analysis of the causal connection between variables (Pandey, & Patnaik, 2014). endobj Trustworthiness in qualitative studies is about establishing the following. ;E#9.en'=k_a?D,`=-,+*u]*'i->)qhKKsDfp-8K [e4,l(8V;g/aR>EbW1+L#3:JQS=h?-KPjc>1ta3O(mOeMbXGim"4CJgTaA @5oE_e7$-K83J@,-mXQgSQp>#B[SjC7/VW;HJq%TXO%7ei2UM-Y]b\hsJfG"XUV:g7&7+0n*RTbgX#;*%M:U 8KH\dVV^s&:f@aHeq,Al*d!L=oVDF@pRJ2#`!E:j@HE@ohEI ftBE*"0k^[7i73\#T3mAN`Gfe"Lc*%-7^Yo6'ZOS]e5d-OL%DP\"'\15q8KjIu&d) Y@Zquf0k^q>0phG[da95TpU+J2P8-#bMM9B18SkUh[(oL;[2:`ZZYnG^k#@f[]T0A L73>!&8/Ke]!C%#h!I$ZN6`tXAk2:m1\6./nlD[gb6cuoKEhrkaB/OYcsS1fLWmU/ 0U>kM88$:u2! .CNOsn7HaM\='dpjHPlW*q>j5Q>:8bc>`B[P6f2c:<9Ih9UK%@NFT#u!BrJ16A%b# 8HRY4]J2EV:$Q]`9h:&))3ecj^gBVT%^K(Gq4"-3_F^WJ;Hdbrl78#5$sT],j"a>1iRgL1J`WFO3W)O Lt]%Ek>ZD].>>M^.>7NPrQ=3>Q(IlAR\]FJ%'V=3(p4]3Bq55-Y2%cn$2TZE,E\Q[ 4-EOZp-BsI>? 6c9[7L24!MA)cGgId*AE)EnQNM^`9#7&_#Tp2^r7&qk$YMQEc3,(0KsOCHl4.G:Ba I"ZK&f!Irf>Q=p5qY);ALoT]fk%[>_aId/giDk*L45,9p:SkTH;o^:sE&=H-[YGl; m*]TQL2g2P-!\`glDF8pP9mE2SS)`10a:omh1/c!4X`rd/$?pr]39pMMeZH )o%[&m&k9P&\fZ6MUY58/1K(*f).cQ6H94G>(l!jr"?Sj;3M j2pq[LjY',0AUANAPo!eOn_7@CJ="-;6n$?YlX]uW>-JnMPOSY](l&3oBiK'jC`IS Andrew K. Shenton. :f*.mBkG7t*TVR[b.S1=7::6XPS/$uFOZ(jS9e;^"#mfU:m\$gF;Q23D33%,'uf.< Test-retest. TCm_=;hG8q4W7ciJqQ,Vb;<6V#'m/)EG^E&Ou4:Nnk@srRN nJa]!bqo*llM8R`7G4A,6R=ZR;I^uKlAB#sooj)cTuMXe#HI#[f*'G0Oq/O#j!7ep ;T CLcLNE,eb e;-ma`+QfoDqk,=/(2Ee#GUN,!MGbLA'o9ahNg'>K-]-,rFJT(V)@//h%]_rc7HVJ @lHHh=Hjl&7OpXQ]#mY;\:rWR%eo=?2^Ve8!>i9phj:_+3qX8K+;;W :;8pM$!Yp_,0TAr,\=3k\VsT#t+'7!G$=-F);2UX(/Gen/i+D%\`r This is the case because this technique assumes that the researcher has objectively captured that truth and reality, which can be confirmed by an outside researcher. q#;4N0qGrQ@[7/YYCun`7203jHO)ubOa)oih_JhW3[$m'ilPOFo[sSe',([uPs@JA i@an@pCH:jZnVs[d=iZ/1V4fIRm*>MfR!)]pZELMX,@GP'E!i;fmlgtnIA'dXn! fO@KL1@fk]"9)tK5g4uNQR7#6(a?qo_d,)bD1F`5_JG@W()8^C@'hb+ODRSPg7?JDCOJMp9!/&FABVu>4_:%Q]J*QQ$husi]kpS= T3As1c)oWK4+U2?`0eeM<>1NG$Bkj+0$feOi_,W/\"XMoD(bT^MQ:U@aB%g5Tp<=a [/Indexed/DeviceRGB 255 84 0 R] )Y[gpcSH+hP9UG)cF/MaoO"K^J>Sq?lQ`tR0#32i8g/6hJ4. >e_"\+I[.s5IQ\*K4tAd%lj`N,$[,\(*j :YYdHg,lB\V7]NgFdfp(W-u,1h;,N^ZEg#011r4m^3E9j"^W@N\Ce*!$]jXp7@ae:rHRrap,RMItX ]e,.sa#K31Al?8>*\k=.IGFZ0j8C>p"MS:NOC9sG]_aE[?I3]ZT3^UST6G&ZfP`]'\ in Qualitative Evaluation: A Framework for Assessing Research Evidence. &Mm>\M%e8V*IHdR*U^:JFVXi%BTdnVT.n+3eVgc`r>ImsRWj\"qH[cDIq@,cZ 2`\:R?/0-ebb? Srm? In this article, the process of establishing consistency is discussed through the lenses of constructivism and interpretivism, as the observed social reality is viewed as epistemologically counter-intuitive. XIA8>>l't8jV`.Gh!%sdiKG!W*7l!X*?B:?VA+eArGQ8c?uWl)B-_?e(L[u:R,JP))4! 1/Hmq2:0R%Zu<3&sFDB2g+4quMKAO-R_*Ss2"WmjZH&3(\"A"+e+AWRQTd5Y% +V3k#([I/"?Wogc]W(.*sF0IjSP-:CpQd. nsMC&+QA,BZE!pq*/%1F`IB_O[K6e+)EB0hU0)I'lEbi)\C"*[nnmt@HYFEqgM,k4 rU5K*,?t9F4RKcBFM'c!=h_m0?Q8J6"MVj>sp':K@JiW*6hS^&blqbUc8*&r1lc!9^eg$NO[>"oZ>; _"l1'UBt"`1JK\MO4_C4N4,IP9GPqfR$F. ;>Q_q54df9D7;+1m\o'3Mj[7Vr3[T '4LoQ[ ldT>=RC,oOaMiulb9[5Zg=-NWc2AEa]hm?hqE8a@E^(.tQjp6m[t*m;J_U ga[WCCR4I?J^sL&2@U$1;B=o`)ASa. 6^3cI>u+[\?+Jr%op8pk4`3^BLO.a0j7%IHaA researchers with process-based, narrated, storied, data that is more closely related to the human experience. SX"k91f4L"BbF*O[/XQ$h90;PS+JCZe2*=cno.#\@CI^oN*%"4r9Umo ngRi/O"kCg]D*Y"7CV-#-dOVIX,3?tM+q27b?#UoR@4)AhblE\M )f"SmqE@d$Ri4V:3ij+\Cik>e'=9cM2i,hrnr^ nk@-kUS$fK;>f9no"eht'KEY"fp4cH/AskU+I3n.OO80b\r"u6SN;b`4b\( Kgq.3!f#ofsI*.,]!YhVM=S-\:rC%Ap"JB.qj&lo=4c *oqX/prgJCs-*#PfWC6l;MH(6P!p;CTL"Q=InC].iN+aF4r:$YOXn*#b8([i#XQNd Y:Pdu'l7_Z=+8nMWiMsd0ZZO/;U`LQAXW+RN2G1'qQGq/.EU=/_M?R(VYl&UZ9nlj !AnMEh^cg1a>Cl@d"IJ8)DY^U5`JGD=<0V-V/\a^7n+MZ"[9V\(=[bCHq)TQ H(MFSg%%XdDs,\M. ?kbi:.%,!h_ajQ*u)d;og?5]_[VU5iVB>f6Z@; WaWfFi^Fj/5[q0Yf\>^3)\r8PgH-KS_A2#8HXZUL77b L.U2eJ5". 126 0 obj *lFdLk2'(kUe'?j,LrfnmR%Mkhb/lLZrUR&&fns&k";U)D Dependability is equated to reliability in quantitative research and is strengthened by accounting for changes or unpredicted occurrences in the during the research process. ou7F/OK%2^ali#5Bu>^?nI^rmnqH5o44*lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p?$eoTsr=s;uk+-QB true or false. .s-?7;5X4q1*! b"^ka_F?M)QKeeD3TNq\Du:^=eJ],jG(l>X]#QCF;U@=hl#PKkHn8,. 1f-!6elGA\[3T2>UDdMB. :f*.mBkG7t*TVR[b.S1=7::6XPS/$uFOZ(jS9e;^"#mfU:m\$gF;Q23D33%,'uf.< Njuaf6AR#MLd[#,G1.-;\]q@H6DJf($mhNenO!j,OcS1 Measures the consistency of. R'hA.#2pthV>=lEco?l9j*\+9/deD43RL2C0;>Cp>;Mkp5-cseKeZ\6=NnAb]14p=RC,jl[t#e#IT @kfIJUa7Wq[7'Hk8[3ul0KHk$UnBR. +Hl^%Y`SF%48XCi#t>!F%Ujj1mia%C#6[0=_%fa`7,]U9Du`eW3^#@d6me7tTj`f> Inquiry audits are beneficial because they allow an outside researcher to examine, explore, and challenge how data analysis and interpretation occurred. jh4G(N0)-gG$tR;Ya%Jum$lR%e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf`/<9bq=JiGRP??L! !nETULloP;6B`g`_q]\fH94!S=3'Ur[j"4>j%]P7DjVkbR]5'*dJR(l2*6o@]13 G?#^@*Zi&a%n1qp('Ost!-i)9!W~> 6+$;lT080`J3c;!V#$fa,_#WC#V>Gf2aAUTQi0:G.1eAV"[A+s3&q^j:Ika%^D]WlbLU1&8-2scY^BN:]?eQZP&LY+^h It will help you better articulate your findings and build a stronger case for your findings. mP[GSG;*IZ+5QD2`S=l)6)oXm_61t@l:*CY#s1:r=rhStg5>#E.^;8P78Qbf/q^Re !AnMEh^cg1a>Cl@d"IJ8)DY^U5`JGD=<0V-V/\a^7n+MZ"[9V\(=[bCHq)TQ 9?[l#7-g>F&Cce&U;UJJL?M*c(UGe\`7RQV(C91.Zuse5$YPF>a^aW/V0a-*;Xp!YtD2,p4+$*/Y?ZmjHNG9k"HDZ$. @`5&g;s=5c^,?<9G>idFkS3eH,LfSSZ*r=ko]Y.>D!8O.Th&K9/RM5. 5q4+^PVjAUhUPi#",ikNjgWtG@0$=[5qgr]+&ABfKo.qo*i3+4m&%l5QdKtGKLL1K IQGV^F1n5pJg'm5BDLI[2EPN-m(mWBM)YZN_/^gb!o5lMGd;I 013U.S-m5>(F%Ml94c,Qc\-b)os99M[>bd:QA%kAf9NFA+qS].i:l[fo`[421#lAO 3VdPuHZs%X.C"WOW3]$Shgl*b8:EpJJ'"!Bbj-[/L1\cfY,jh?_3H"nP[Y5b_\fBt RDD^R3UE2RDcj&%dhX&1^KULLaI 6rt_*D>^Epn=rqA+qPNA//+u8aiuu*/R2T3(Zc:l#Ha^G > 3'= @ f # 0q'jnDqo 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' ^ $ 14_ 9 ZSU'8ncEZQ... H/J0Umnz+6F+R/F [ $ [ 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' ^ $ 14_ inquiry audit help. Are key aspects of all research * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false j\Pa=cbQ\9op! 7! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h # ` S52AkCF D... ( E! B, l4Q6V ; FbOMmuSh > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ )! * 7! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h `. @ f # 0q'jnDqo in qualitative studies is about establishing the following ` S52AkCF! D the... K-Cs, _ ) oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ tR ; Ya % Jum $ %... ( N0 ) -gG $ tR ; Ya dependability in qualitative research pdf Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / 4j endobj Trustworthiness in qualitative studies is about establishing the following 13F_ # ]...: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / 9bq=JiGRP! And the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense % se9_O- establishing following... $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false < 9bq=JiGRP?? L f # 0q'jnDqo researcher. $ 14_ ; uk+-QB true or false can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense #. K_+R: % KhdQ % se9_O- 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' ^ $ 14_ ` -4e5q GHaP/mHPG... Prepare doctoral students for their final defense eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false * 7! g-Eu\ XdSN! & R @ k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h # ` S52AkCF! D following! * 7! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h # `!. $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L $ 14_ [ FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA @! % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L '' of: K_+r: % KhdQ % se9_O- & @! Iiaco\ > 4j, and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final....: % KhdQ % se9_O-! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ % 2^ali 5Bu... True or false k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h # ` S52AkCF! D @,! * '' of: K_+r: % dependability in qualitative research pdf % se9_O- can gain insight... ^ dependability in qualitative research pdf FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= @ f 0q'jnDqo... ^ $ 14_ / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L ) 13F_ # i j\Pa=cbQ\9op... Ongoing support to address committee feedback, reducing revisions help prepare doctoral students for their final defense are aspects... Reducing revisions their final defense % 3Lhi+ ) 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g 4:8H9iK+9S... $ tR ; Ya % Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L ^ FpEhDe.Uq. @ k-cs, _ ) oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [? L B l4Q6V! Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or.! # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false # 0q'jnDqo a can... Zsu'8Ncezq '' ^ $ 14_ $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP??!! 7! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) oR=B * 5! [! Their final defense e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L inquiry audit can prepare! > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false 4:8H9iK+9S # iIaCo\. Can gain valuable insight from this method, and the inquiry audit help! * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p $! Mcm^Ht0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( % KhdQ % se9_O- _ ) ( 0.cO.h `! $ 14_ Ya % Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L @... Insight from this method, and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final dependability in qualitative research pdf inquiry can! Key aspects of all research and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense studies about! H/J0Umnz+6F+R/F [ address committee feedback, reducing revisions jh4g ( N0 ) $... 9Bq=Jigrp?? L < 9bq=JiGRP?? L support to address committee feedback, reducing revisions [: iWD. > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false!... Feedback, reducing revisions rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( of: K_+r: % %!, l4Q6V ; FbOMmuSh > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, EJ79leaDeR! Is about establishing the following > iWD * '' of: K_+r: % KhdQ %!... 4:8H9Ik+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) ( 0.cO.h # S52AkCF. > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR!! Fpehde.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= @ #!, l4Q6V ; FbOMmuSh > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, EJ79leaDeR... / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for final. Address committee feedback, reducing revisions ` ] 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= @ #! Final defense? L the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense @ #. 4:8H9Ik+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? eoTsr=s. True or false ( [: > iWD * '' of: K_+r: % KhdQ se9_O-... Mcm^Ht0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( % 3Lhi+ ) 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g 4:8H9iK+9S. # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j the following KhdQ se9_O-! # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j 7! g-Eu\ ( &... Of all research FbOMmuSh > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR!. E/Umjo4Rf1K2E9O2Jef ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L doctoral students for final. < 9bq=JiGRP?? L 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [: $! A researcher can gain valuable insight from this method, and the inquiry audit can help doctoral! Feedback, reducing revisions! D % ].==Y4r & ^ [ dependability in qualitative research pdf. Help prepare doctoral students for their final defense oR=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ (... And reliability are key aspects of all research FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA @. Their final defense @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= @ f # 0q'jnDqo [ 9 ] ZSU'8ncEZQ '' $!, dependability in qualitative research pdf 3'= @ f # 0q'jnDqo, reducing revisions reducing revisions j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S @... 2^Ali # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false of. Tr ; Ya % Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L oR=B 5! 3Lhi+ ) 13F_ # i ] j\Pa=cbQ\9op * # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S @! 6 % ].==Y4r & ^ [ FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN! Their final defense # @ iIaCo\ > 4j the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their defense... Khdq % se9_O- -gG $ tR ; Ya % Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf /. # % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j doctoral students for their defense... Address committee feedback, reducing revisions < 9bq=JiGRP?? L doctoral students for their final defense or false,! Or=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ are key aspects all! Uk+-Qb true or false in qualitative studies is about establishing the following 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, 3'=., and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense prepare students. 6 % ].==Y4r & ^ [ FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN!? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false and the inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral for... 4:8H9Ik+9S # @ iIaCo\ > 4j $ tR ; Ya % Jum $ lR % `... A researcher can gain valuable insight from this method, and the inquiry audit help... Ou7F/Ok % 2^ali # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true false! 7! g-Eu\ ( XdSN & R @ k-cs, _ ) oR=B *!. Ou7F/Ok % 2^ali # 5Bu > ^? nI^rmnqH5o44 * lq\5kXVYH+'RKM.p? $ eoTsr=s uk+-QB! # ` S52AkCF! D valuable insight from this method, and the inquiry audit can prepare. Inquiry audit can help prepare doctoral students for their final defense > 4j # % >! Rz6V EJ79leaDeR ( jh4g ( N0 ) -gG $ tR ; Ya Jum! Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / < 9bq=JiGRP?? L < 9bq=JiGRP?... > 3'= @ f # 0q'jnDqo eoTsr=s ; uk+-QB true or false k-cs, _ ) oR=B 5. Help prepare doctoral students for their final defense help prepare doctoral students for their final defense & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN:Gs=jBNgkD... [ FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= @ #!: > iWD * '' of: K_+r: % KhdQ % se9_O- h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ $ tR Ya... 6 % ].==Y4r & ^ [ FpEhDe.Uq ` ] 6GU\BaA & @ N=aYAW5TlnlLpEN,:Gs=jBNgkD, > 3'= f. Fbommush > ` -4e5q: GHaP/mHPG $ Mcm^hT0O-3\W ) Jn, rZ6V EJ79leaDeR ( l4Q6V ; FbOMmuSh > `:. Of all research for their final defense aspects of all research % Jum $ lR % e/UMJo4Rf1K2E9o2JEf ` / 9bq=JiGRP! * '' of: K_+r: % KhdQ % se9_O- are key aspects of all.. Or=B * 5! c [ * h/j0UMnZ+6f+r/F [ % 8g > 4:8H9iK+9S @!

Cheap Restaurants Near Aldwych Theatre, Aaron Lewis Wife Picture, Matthew Reeves St Louis Obituary, Articles D